RAN Technology


 Posted By: Robert Nickels (ranickels)
Posted: 06/06/2020

Technical 06/06/2020 

Class E Notes

the result of experiments with high efficiency class E amplifiers


 

There is a lot of misunderstanding about how a Class E amplifier works.     As the result of studying the literature and experimenting, I thought I'd share what I have learned over the past several years.   

Below is an example of a test amplifier I used to optimize my 2 watt wspr transmitter boards.   It can be visualized as two circuits - the amplifier itself and an impedance matching section.    The amplifier consists of the swtich (NMOS FET), a parallel capacitor, and a series tuned circut.    The shunt (parallel) capacitor adds to the Coss capacitance of the FET as part of the tuned circuit, but also acts to limit the voltage across the FET when it is turned off, and to widen the off-time waveform.   The value is not super-critical but it must be capable of withstanding at least 3.5X the drain voltage and should be mounted as close as physically possible to the FET (ideally right across the leads) because inductance here will add harmonics to the output.   The fundamental issue with all class E designs is that while NMOS FETs make nearly ideal switches, the gate structure is basically a capacitor, and the higher the power capability, the larger the gate capacitance becomes, and as the nice square edges of the drive signal are rounded off, the less efficient the switch becomes.     Fortunately this issue is manageable with the devices used at QRP power levels where digital logic ICs (especially the 74AC family) can do the job.   There are many low-side FET driver ICs on the market that work great for power supplies, but sadly most of them are not fast enough for RF.

Contrary to intuition, the series network is not made resonant at the operating frequency, and is slightly reactive (resonates lower in frequency).   This is because the goal when optimizing a class E amplifier is to minimize the time when the voltage and current across the switch (FET) are both high.  Graphically, an ideal class E drain waveform has several key characteristics that are described in the inventor's paper, but which look like the attached "Ideal waveform" photo.    In my experience (and verified by more seasoned class E designers), formulas and design aids get you in the ballpark, but simulation (I use ltspice) and actual lab testing are required to arrive at an efficient optimized design where efficiency even greater than 90% are achieved.

As proof of this, the experimenter will soon discover that the answers provided by various online and downloadable class E design aids do not always agree.  However I will list several here with the usual advice that "YMMV":

VK1SV online calculator

WAØITP downloadable class E spreadsheet

Tonne Software downloadable ClassE design aid

VK2ZAY online tool

NU2B downloadable design tools (DOS and xls)

And for those who wish to go straight to the source, the design equations can be found in the inventor, Nathan Sokal's article "Class E Power Amplifiers" in QEX for Jan-Feb 2001.     Further information can be found in research papers and in US Patent No. 3,919,656 that he and his son obtained in 1975.     This article is copyright by ARRL so is not included here but may be found online  LINK

 

The WAØITP spreadsheet has always produced "good ballpark" efficiency for me by using nearest standard values to those specified by the spreadsheet and is my recommended best choice of design tools.    This tool calculates the values fo Dave Cripe's design which has been proven in many applications.

However you get there, the bottom line is:  if you don't have this waveform, you don't have class E.    The design process involves tweaking and adjusting to optimize the drain waveform, because that is the heart of the efficiency of  the class E design.   Ohms Law tells us, P=E*I, so minimizing E and I means the amount of power dissipated in the transistor is minimized.   A typical optimized class E amplifier will be able to convert at least 80% of input power into RF, i.e.. 80% efficiency.   That is compared with 50-60% for a class C amplifier, and as high as 90% is possible.

The problem is, the output impedance of most class E amplifiers is not 50 ohms, and because of the square wave switching, harmonics are present - the 2nd harmonic is usually the strongest by far.    Thus an impedance matching stage is required, and a  harmonic filter.    The circuit below accomplished both with the fewest parts:


Description Comment  
Cripe push-pull patent
WAØITP Class E Design Spreadsheet
Class E amplifiers by Dan Tayloe from 2004
NA5N part 1
NMØS paper from 2009
NA5N part 2
Infineon wireless power ap note
   

Crystal Replacement
Posted: 02/38/2024
Comments: 0
How good can a crummy receiver be?

Hundreds of different simple SDR receivers have been designed around Dan Tayloe's Quadrature Sampling Detector or QSD.   Mine add nothing to the state of the art, and in fact subtract things, as I like minimalist solutions and the QSD is right in that sweet spot.   Following the evolution of Tayloe's design I delete the resistors in series with the sample lines for inst...  READ MORE

Technical
Posted: 02/37/2024
Comments: 0
What's in a number (3253)?

The FST3253 dual four-to-one mux/demux IC has long been used as a "Tayloe Detector" or QSD (and QSE) in low-cost SDRs.   They provide incredible performance for such a simple circuit, converting RF to baseband IQ with low loss and the ultimate in simplicity. Unfortunately the original FST3253 part has become obsolete and while substitutes are available, this is where the...  READ MORE

Vintage Ham Radio
Posted: 02/32/2024
Comments: 0
The Stancor 10P Transmitter

There weren't really many commercial transmitters in the 1930s as most hams built their own.   But many of the ones that were offered came from the transformer companies who had two chances to profit.   First, from those who would buy the kit, and two, from those would would see it in the (free) booklets the companies provided to their distributors who would then sell the iron to ham...  READ MORE

Vintage Ham Radio
Posted: 12/355/2023
Comments: 0
The Care and Feeding of the EF Johnson Courier amplifier

The EF Johnson "Courier" is a grid-driven amplifier using two 811A tubes.   Switching is provided for operating in either class C for CW or as a class B linear amplifier for AM or SSB.   Rated power is 500 watts input for CW, 500 watts PEP input for SSB, and 200 watts input for double-sideband AM with carrier.    Since all amateur power levels were meas...  READ MORE

Historic
Posted: 11/329/2023
Comments: 0
TV Duplexer

Some things are interesting, even if totally useless nowadays.   Such is the case with the Philco 426-3034 Crossover Kit for UHF TV.   What the heck is that? Well, back in the late 50s,  UHF television stations operating on channels 14-83 started to appear in many areas of the US where viewers had a VHF-only TV antenna, and in many cases an externa UHF converter was...  READ MORE

Crystal Replacement
Posted: 11/327/2023
Comments: 0
Replacing failed crystals

For decades, quartz crystals were used everywhere a stable frequency source was needed, even in some applications that depended on overtone (harmonic) behavior into the VHF range.   These crystals were less stable and more dependent on circuit parameters that fundamental types and thus more problematic.    Such was the case with the 94 MHz crystal in the 2 meter converter ...  READ MORE

Historic
Posted: 11/315/2023
Comments: 0
My Own Ham Radio Story by W9RAN

Everyone has a story of how they got involved in ham radio - this is mine.   It started much earlier, including receiving a Knight Kit Span Master shortwave radio for Christmas in about 1963, at age 12.   I'll never forget the night my dad and I finished building it and I wanted to try it out.   It came with a 50 ft. antenna which was still coiled up - but ...  READ MORE

Technical
Posted: 09/267/2023
Comments: 0
Hot to simulate vacuum tubes in LTSpice

LTSice is a powerful simulation tool that is provided free by Linear Technology Corp.   It comes with a complete library of passive and common analog solid-state components but if you want to use it to simulate vacuum tubes, it doesen't work as-is.    Even though triode and pentode symbols can be found in the "Misc" folder, they are just schematic symbols and...  READ MORE

Friends Remembered
Posted: 07/208/2023
Comments: 0
Merv Schweigert, K9FD (SK)

Comments from Robert Nickels W9RAN,  July 27, 2023: There is nothing worse for a ham radio operator than to see a beloved friends callsign with the letters "SK" behind them.   Yet sadly, that's what happened on July 23, 2023, when I learned of the passsing of Merv Schweigert, K9FD.     While many of our ham radio interests were different - Me...  READ MORE

Vintage Ham Radio
Posted: 01/19/2023
Comments: 0
"Winter Projects"

I know many of us who enjoy restoring and repairing vintage gear look forward to winter when there is less competition for time and energy, and a chance to really make a dent in our "to be fixed" piles.    A couple of years ago I set time aside for "Heathkit Singlebander Week" and went through every one of them I had, with the result that they're all working ...  READ MORE