RAN Technology

Spectral Purity using Epson Programmable Oscillators


Crystal Replacement 0 Comments 03/12/2019 

Do harmonics matter if there's no way for them to be heard?

Posted By: Robert Nickels (ranickels)

 

In the 5 or so years I've been using the Epson oscillators I've looked at the spectral output many times.   Without a doubt the harmonic output from the Epson oscillator is high as would be expected  from a square wave device.   The question to me has always been "does it matter"?

PLL controlled digital oscillators have long been used as LOs in receivers and transceivers, including the Si570 and Si5351 which also have square wave outputs with high harmonic content, so I felt the Epson oscillators should be no different, and that has been my experience.    I've also used the clock generation capability of the Raspberry Pi extensively for wspr, which is also a square wave signal that is nicely filtered by use of a  7 pole low-pass filter taken straight from the GQRP harmonic filter guide.    I've also designed my own lowpass and bandpass filters for wspr using Elsie which  work equally well with spots from around the world using 40 milliwatts of power.

All of which is to say - if you want a clean output directly from the oscillator you will need a filter to remove harmonics.   However my primary interest in using the Epson oscillators is for crystal replacement in radios where they either provide injection to a mixer or drive amplifier stages, all of which already have tuned circuits that are resonant at the frequency of interest.   I've done the comparison vs quartz crystals numerous times and the answer has always come up the same:   the spectral purity using the Epson oscillator is no different from using a crystal.

That said, we all know that merely using a crystal guarantees the absence of harmonic content (which is why hams have used low pass filters and sometimes received pink tickets!)    But my point is that the harmonic attenuation provide by the transmitter is the same with a crystal or an Epson - it's a function of the transmitter itself.    Many hams use antenna tuners nowadays which provides additional high selectivity to prevent whatever harmonics may be present from radiating far.

Today, FCC part 97.307 requires 43dB attenuation of HF harmonics for radios built since 2003,  40dB for those built between 1978 and 2003 (30dB for < 5 watt rigs), and those built prior to 1978 are exempt.   Even though crystal replacement in boatanchors is thus exempt from 97.307, it's always been my goal to at least come  close or if possible to meet the FCC regulation, or at least to be no worse than the same radio is using crystal control.   Attached are three comparisons of  Epson oscillators showing the spectral output for various configurations:

1.   Raw Epson vs. G-QRP LPF.    This shows the attenuation provided by the 7 pole 20 meter LPF per the attached design guide.   While the harmonics are still present, they are attenuated by around 40dB.

2.   HW-16 - comparison showing there is no difference in harmonic content whether a crystal or an Epson oscillator is used (this is with the Epson oscillator driving a one transistor broadband amplifier of my own design).    The second harmonic is down about 38dB and the third is actually better than the crystal.

3.  Bendix Skipper 101 Marine radio.  The "crystal" spectrum is the normal  2-tube transmitter using a a 12AQ5 oscillator driving a 12JB6 PA for about 20 watts output.   The second plot shows the output of the untuned amplifier connected directly to the grid of the PA tube, bypassing the crystal oscillator stage in he the radio entirely  (it is also untuned).   No difference in harmonic output can be seen with both providing about 36dB attenuation of the second harmonic.

4.  My experience says that tuned circuits in radios are highly effective at removing harmonic content when Epson oscillators are used to drive tube type transmitters and all kinds of mixers.   A parallel resonant tank using a 2.2uH inductor and combination of fixed and variable capacitor was adjusted to resonate at the 13.85MHz frequency and coupled it to the output of my untuned amplifier.    A two-turn link enabled the spectrum analyzer to create the "tank" plot which shows about 30dB attenuation.  (I would also note that this was a "lash-up" of two existing boards using short leads but not optimal RF wiring and grounding practice and a properly designed tuned RF amplifier could no doubt be even better).

We use class C RF amplifiers because they provide high efficiency, but at the cost of high harmonic distortion.  That's why they are invariably used with tuned loads that are resonant at the frequency of interest.   So even if we fed a perfect sine wave into a class C amplifier, it will create it's own distortion that must be filtered out.    To my way of thinking this is why none of the transmitters I've tried Epson oscillators with cares whether the input waveform is sine or square -  the class C PA is biased such that it is conducting less than half the time and relies on the flywheel effect of the resonant tank to keep the sine wave going during the non-conducting portion of the cycle.

If you use the Epson oscillators in a stand-alone mode or with an amplifier, I strongly suggest using either a LPF or tuned output circuit in the amplifier - the data presented here offers a guide as to the degree of spectral purity that can be obtained using LPF and tuned circuits.   But for general crystal replacement, it is clear that the harmonics present in the square wave output have no more impact on harmonic generation from a typical transmitter than when using a quartz crystal for frequency control.


Description Comment  
G-QRP harmonic filters by G3RJV

   What can I say, I like oddball radios!    There was already a different version of this CAI SSB-125 on my shelf but it had the remote control head, and this one was cheap, well under $100 including shipping, and I'm easily amused.   Communications Associates Inc. was a supplier of commercial, military, and marine radios based in Huntington Station, NY but I haven&...  READ MORE
- Robert Nickels (ranickels),  05/14/2020 
   The HW-16 had to be pushed aside while waiting for parts, creating an opening just big enough for the homebrew receiver I got recently via eBay for $18.50 - plus 2X that to ship it here.   I like saving and restoring old homebrew gear just out of respect for the amount of time and effort our forefathers put into making things from scratch, and this receiver intrigued me, as the IF transf...  READ MORE
- Robert Nickels (ranickels),  04/28/2020 
    The Multi Elmac Company of Hazel Park and later, Oak Park MI is best know amongst hams for it's great mobile transmitters and receivers which were probably the most popular rigs of their type and are still often used on AM today.   The Multi Elmac Net pays tribute to these little rigs by and typically a half-dozen or more are heard on the net weekly.But the company's origin...  READ MORE
- Robert Nickels (ranickels),  04/22/2020 
  

Wireless on a Train

a lesser-known radio "first"
Category: Historic
WHEN Frederick Wally stepped out of a little cubby-hole in one corner of the forward day coach on the Lackawanna Limited, west-bound, as it neared North Scranton, Pennsylvania, Tuesday, November 25, 1913, and pinned a sheet of paper on the wall, the passengers in the front seats, who had been casually wondering what caused the strange, crackling sounds that had been coming from the cubby-hole, pri...  READ MORE
- Robert Nickels (ranickels),  04/14/2020 
    The  Dentron MLX-MINII thought it would be cool to use the Dentron MLX-MINI on the Saturday Vintage Sideband Net but it's a little marginal since the rule is "no tubes, go home!".   However hybrid rigs are allowed, and Special Dispensation is given for rigs with Red LEDs.    So I thought the MLX was double-qualifed - even more so after I realized t...  READ MORE
- Robert Nickels (ranickels),  04/04/2020 
  

AMECO - one of the forgotten ham manufacturers?

A company that was part of ham radio for over 50 years
Category: Vintage Ham Radio
The internet knows a lot about ham radio history, but not so much about a company that everyone recognizes:   The American Elecronic Company - AMECO.AMECO - American Electronics Co.; New York 53, N.Y (1950s).Manufacturer of HAM radio equipment.Also: AMECO - Division of Aerotron Inc., Raleigh, North Carolina (1968).Also: AMECO - Ameco Equipment Corp.; 178 Herricks Road Mineola, L.I. New Y...  READ MORE
- Robert Nickels (ranickels),  03/29/2020 
  

Mix and Match Radios

VERSA-TR makes it easy to play radio
Category: VERSA-TR Information
I like to play radio!   As a SWL and novice, I'd imagine owning different transmitters and receivers and now that I actually DO own many of them, it's fun to "mix and match" to put them on the air.     That's mainly why I developed the VERSA-TR, which is an RF-sensing T/R and muting switch, so I could easily change out transmitters and receivers ...  READ MORE
- Robert Nickels (ranickels),  03/07/2020 
  

An Unbreakable Code

Navajo Code Talkers in the battle for Iwo Jima
Category: Historic
The Code Talkers used native languages to send military messages before World War II. Choctaw, for example, was successfully used during World War I. But the Marine Corps needed an “unbreakable” code for its island-hopping campaign in the Pacific. Navajo, which was unwritten and known by few outside the tribe, seemed to fit the Corps’ requirements. Twenty-nine Navajos were recrui...  READ MORE
- Robert Nickels (ranickels),  03/06/2020 
   Faust Gonsett started the Sideband Engineers (SBE) company in 1962 and introduced their first product, the SB-33 four-band transceiver with a two-page ad in 73 magazine for February 1963 that featured his mugshot on the left page and the introductory ad for the SB-33 on the right.   He talks about how he came out of retirement to start this new company in response to many requests but do...  READ MORE
- Robert Nickels (ranickels),  02/15/2020 
   Well known radio repair guru and AM fan Jeff Covelli WA8SAJ of Cleveland OH wanted better receiving performance than his stock Nouveau 75 AM transceiver provided - and the VERSA-TR came to the rescue.  Jeff decided he preferred having the board mounted in an enclosure with connectors and the photos show his approach.    The VERSA-TR automatically switches the antenna from his S...  READ MORE
- Robert Nickels (ranickels),  02/11/2020 

VIEW News Item

Announcing the W9DYV Radio Society

honoring SSB pioneer Wes Schum W9DYV
VIEW News Item

Making A Transistor Radio

in memory of Rev. George Dobbs G3RJV (SK)
VIEW News Item

Soviet Spy Radio found in forest

(oh yeah, I put that there...I'll take it now thanks!)
VIEW News Item

Take the Boatanchor Survey!

Let authors and organizers know what you're interested in
VIEW News Item

W9RAN's "VERSA-TR" (as featured in Dec. 2018 QST)

A Versatile T/R solution for SDRs and vintage radios
VIEW News Item

MICROPHONIA! is here

Cool mics from my collection and ones I wish were
VIEW News Item

WBBM-AM tower moves to Bloomington IL

watch the old tower fall (video link below)

(There are currently no Blogs.)