RAN Technology

The Case of the Phantom Voltage

Technical 0 Comments 02/08/2019 

“When you have eliminated all which is impossible, then whatever remains, however improbable, must be the truth.”

Posted By: Robert Nickels (ranickels)

A Heathkit HW-12 gave me a troubleshooting challenge the likes of which I've not seen before - or even heard of!

A few days ago the transmitter wouldn't produce output, and in checking voltages and I measured -75 volts on the ALC line which should be -20.   But it corrected itself and I figured it must have been a solder splash or something that cleared by itself.  That theory lasted until the voltage returned and wouldn't go away - so I had to get serious about fixing this weird problem.

After several hours of going in circles I'd reached the point where  I'd stare at the schematic trying to rationalize what magic was at work.   It made no sense because the source of the voltage I was measuring was a voltage divider that came thru the bias pot where all the resistors had the correct resistance, yet the voltage on the ALC line was three times what it should be.     I've highlighted the circuit in question in yellow on the schematic below.

The resistors all measured within tolerance, I even checked the caps and diode for leakage but they were all fine.   Yet the phantom voltage persisted!

Finally I was tired of it all and went into what I call "TV repairman mode".  No longer caring about theory, thinking it out, etc - I just wanted the thing fixed!   So I pulled one end of each component attached to that circuit board trace loose ( R79, R78, C74, and one more that's off this page).   This left nothing connected to the PC board trace at all, yet with power off I measured 15K ohms to an adjacent trace!   I got out my isopropyl alcohol and scrubbed and cleaned the flux residue, ran my knife blade between the traces to remove whatever resistive material I couldn't see.   And due to a late-night measurement error I thought I'd fixed the problem, so I soldered everything back, but the -75 volts was still present!   At this point I did the only smart thing and went to bed!

The next morning's plan was based on the famous Sherlock Homes quote:   “When you have eliminated all which is impossible, then whatever remains, however improbable, must be the truth.”   I've been designing and using PC boards for over 40 years but despite never having seen one develop this kind of conductivity between traces, the only conclusion is that was happening.   To prove it, I again disconnected all components from the trace in question and with power applied I measured more than -75 volts on the bare PCB trace with nothing connected to it!    The adjacent traces on either side also carry bias voltage, and one or both of them are obviously the source of the phantom voltage via leakage through the PC board material.   Like many consumer products at the time, Heathkit did not use glass-epoxy laminate (like G-10 or FR-4) for their PC boards, but rather the brown-colored reinforced phenolic material (typically grade XXXP).   An industry source provides this information about this material:

"These grades are composed of a paper base impregnated with a phenolic resin binder. Phenolics are the oldest, best-known general purpose thermoset resins. They are among the lowest cost and easiest to process. Phenolics are quite adequate for a fair percentage of electrical applications. Generally speaking, they are not equivalent to epoxies in resistance to moisture, humidity, dimensional stability, shrinkage and retention of electrical properties in extreme environments."

For future reference, I've noted the components and circuit board trace on this marked-up drawing:

My conclusion is that this particular HW-12 may have been exposed to conditions that caused the weaknesses of XXXP material to become a factor.   Also, if you examine this circuit, it is a high impedance (>1M) circuit that controls the bias of the transmit IF amplifier, so there is nothing to bleed off the phantom voltage that is leaking through the PC board (which now typically is measured to be around 100K between this trace and the adjacent ones).

The solution was to hardwire these connections without using the PC board trace, and now the voltages are normal and the radio works as it should.   The bottom line?   Once you know the answer, it's elementary, my dear Holmes!

   The following obituary appeared in the Freeport Journal-Standard on Febr. 9, 2019.      I attended a lecture by Mr. Anderson in the late 1990s after moving to Freeport and working for Honeywell where despite being a supplier to DEC, few realized the local connection existed to the founder of what once was the second-largest computer company in the world.   Mr. Anderso...  READ MORE
- Robert Nickels (ranickels),  02/09/2019 

The Solvay Conference, 1927

The Smartest Photograph Ever Take
Category: Historic
The Solvay Conference, founded by the Belgian industrialist Ernest Solvay in 1912, was considered a turning point in the world of physics. Located in Brussels, the conferences were devoted to outstanding preeminent open problems in both physics and chemistry. The most famous conference was the October 1927 Fifth Solvay International Conference on Electrons and Photons, where the world’s most...  READ MORE
- Robert Nickels (ranickels),  12/27/2018 
   Put yourself in 1963...A stamp was a nickel, bread was 22 cents a loaf, and you could buy 3 gallons of gas for a buck.   The average wage in the US was $84 a week.  If you were a ham, you might have been able to build and trade your way up to a really nice AM/CW station - maybe a Valiant or DX-100 transmitter with an NC-300 or HQ-170 receiver - a huge improvement over the S-38 you s...  READ MORE
- Robert Nickels (ranickels),  12/17/2018 

Astro...Don Stoner's legacy

How many of these rare transceivers have you seen?
Category: Vintage Ham Radio
A recent post on the Cubic-Astro mail reflector noted the similarities between the rare CIR Astro 200 and the much more common Cubic Astro 150 transceivers.   And therein lies an  interesting story...I have done a little research on the CIR Astro 200, and the commenter was right - it is the progenitor of the Astro line we are much more familiar with as a result of Swan (already owne...  READ MORE
- Robert Nickels (ranickels),  12/09/2018 

The DX-60 Family

what hath Benton Harbor wrought?
Category: Vintage Ham Radio
When an engineer at Heathkit in 1962 turned his attention to designing a replacement for the somewhat flawed DX-40 novice transmitter, little would he have expected the DX-60 to remain in the Heathkit catalog for 14 years.    From the new solid-state power supply to the streamlined apeperance and dependable performace, the new transmitter was instantly popular with novices who had t...  READ MORE
- Robert Nickels (ranickels),  12/09/2018 
   Epson programmable oscillators are a good substitute for quartz crystals in many applications, but they're a bit different to use.   First, they are active devices that require DC power, typically 5 volts at 45mA.    Second, like all ICs they are easily damaged by static and voltages that exceed the design limits.   Finally they are in DIP packates that are i...  READ MORE
- Robert Nickels (ranickels),  12/08/2018 

Programmable Oscillators - the modern day "rock"

Cheaper and more accurate and stable than the old type
Category: Crystal Replacement
With the demise of  International Crystal in 2018, hams and experimenters lost the last US-based source of affordable one-off custom crystals.  (And the definition of "affordable" ended up over $30 each).     Sure there are some offshore sources but the reality is, manufacturing one crystal to a specific frequency is not simple or inexpensive, and all crysta...  READ MORE
- Robert Nickels (ranickels),  12/06/2018 

"A Pair of 6V6s"

What more does one need to hear good audio?
Category: Vintage Audio
The first audio amplififer I made (that worked) used a single 6V6 to amplify the output of a regenerative receiver.    Ever since they've been my idea of what a good audio tube should be and with a big speaker mounted on a piece of plywood, a 6V6 will produce "room filling volume" as the magazine articles fo the day said.   But as my music tastes grew acousti...  READ MORE
- Robert Nickels (ranickels),  12/03/2018 
   My primary aim when desiging the VERSA-TR was low power transmitters, and to protect the receiver from potentially damaging voltages when transmitting. 100 watts into 50 ohms is a +50dBm signal.  I'd measured the attenuation at the receiver connector in the labe at -60 to -70 dB (depending on frequency), which means that should result in -10 to -20dB at the receiver, which should be ...  READ MORE
- Robert Nickels (ranickels),  11/29/2018 

VIEW News Item

Take the Boatanchor Survey!

Let authors and organizers know what you're interested in
VIEW News Item

Announcing the VERSA-TR (as seen in Dec. 2018 QST)

A Versatile T/R solution for SDRs and vintage radios
VIEW News Item

Mike Beachy N8ECR - SK

"If there's a ham radio heaven, they've got a hell of a net control operator"
VIEW News Item

K9QET Update

AM stalwart net control op and all-round good guy needs your thoughts and prayers
VIEW News Item

DX-60 Website Announced

Celebrating the fun of low-power AM

(There are currently no Blogs.)